Blog

A DOL starter, or Direct-On-Line starter, is the simplest and most common method used to start three-phase induction motors.

In a DOL starter, the motor is directly connected to the full voltage of the power supply during the starting process. This means that the motor receives the full line voltage right from the beginning.

Here’s how a DOL starter works:

1. Start Button Pressed: When the start button is pressed, a contactor (a type of electrical relay) closes, allowing the full voltage to be applied directly to the motor terminals.

2. High Starting Current: The motor experiences a high inrush current during the initial connection, which can be several times the rated current of the motor.

3. Full Torque: The motor starts with full torque right from the beginning, accelerating the connected load.

DOL starters are commonly used for small- to medium-sized motors where the high inrush current is acceptable and does not cause significant issues in the power supply or electrical system.

They are cost-effective, simple, and easy to implement. However, the high starting current can lead to voltage dips in the power supply system, and the mechanical stress on the motor and connected equipment is higher during the starting phase compared to other starting methods.

Key features and considerations of DOL starters include:

• Simplicity: DOL starters are straightforward in design and operation, consisting of a contactor, start button, stop button, and overload relay for motor protection.

• Cost-Effective: DOL starters are typically less expensive compared to more sophisticated motor starting methods.

• High Inrush Current: The main drawback is the high inrush current during starting, which can impact the power supply and electrical system.

• Suitability for Small to Medium Motors: DOL starters are well-suited for motors where the starting current is within acceptable limits for the system.

• Mechanical Stress: The abrupt application of full voltage can result in mechanical stress on the motor and connected equipment.

While DOL starters are commonly used, for larger motors or applications where a more controlled starting current is required, alternative starting methods such as star-delta starters, soft starters, or variable frequency drives (VFDs) may be employed to mitigate the impact of high inrush currents and provide more controlled acceleration.

A star-delta starter is a type of reduced voltage starter used for three-phase induction motors. It is designed to reduce the high starting current that occurs during the direct-on-line (DOL) starting of such motors.

The star-delta starter achieves this by initially connecting the motor windings in a star (wye) configuration during the starting sequence and then switching to a delta configuration for normal operation.

Here’s how the star-delta starting sequence works:

1. Star Connection (Starting): During the starting sequence, the motor windings are initially connected in a star (Y) configuration. This reduces the voltage across each winding, resulting in a reduction of the starting current. The motor starts with reduced torque during this phase.

2. Transition Period: The motor operates in the star configuration for a predetermined period, allowing it to reach a certain speed.

3. Delta Connection (Running): After the preset time (typically a few seconds), the motor is switched to a delta (Δ) configuration. This reconnects the windings in a way that the motor receives the full line voltage, providing full torque for normal running.

The primary purpose of the star-delta starter is to minimize the inrush current during motor starting, which helps prevent voltage drops in the power supply system and reduces the mechanical stress on the motor and connected equipment.

Key features and advantages of a star-delta starter include:

• Reduced Starting Current: The star-delta starter significantly reduces the starting current compared to direct-on-line starting, which is beneficial for systems with limited capacity or where high inrush currents are undesirable.

• Smooth Starting Transition: The transition from star to delta connection is often automated and provides a smoother starting sequence, minimizing mechanical and electrical shocks during the motor start.

• Application to Large Motors: Star-delta starters are commonly used for larger three-phase induction motors where the starting current is substantial and needs to be controlled.

• Voltage Drop Mitigation: By reducing the starting current, the star-delta starter helps prevent significant voltage drops in the electrical distribution system during motor starting.

It’s important to note that the design and implementation of star-delta starters may vary based on specific motor and application requirements.

Additionally, modern motor control systems may use electronic soft starters or variable frequency drives (VFDs) as alternatives to achieve controlled motor starting with even more flexibility and energy efficiency.

Direct On Line (DOL) starter and Star-Delta starter are two different methods used for starting three-phase induction motors. Each method has its own advantages and applications. Here’s a brief comparison:

1. Starting Method:

   • DOL Starter: In a DOL starter, the motor is directly connected to the full voltage of the power supply during the start. This results in a sudden and high starting current.
   • Star-Delta Starter: In a Star-Delta starter, the motor is initially connected in a star configuration during the start, which reduces the voltage across each winding. After a specific time (typically a few seconds), the motor is switched to a delta configuration for normal running.

2. Starting Current:

   • DOL Starter: High starting current, which can be several times the rated current of the motor.
   • Star-Delta Starter: The star connection during the starting sequence reduces the starting current compared to DOL, but it is still higher than the normal running current.

3. Torque during Start:

   • DOL Starter: Provides full starting torque right from the beginning.
   • Star-Delta Starter: Provides reduced starting torque during the star connection phase, which increases to full torque when switched to delta.

4. Application:

   • DOL Starter: Typically used for smaller motors where the high starting current is acceptable, or when the system has sufficient capacity to handle the inrush current.
   • Star-Delta Starter: Commonly used for larger motors where the starting current needs to be reduced to minimize voltage drop and prevent excessive demand on the power supply.

5. Cost:

   • DOL Starter: Generally simpler and less expensive.
   • Star-Delta Starter: Requires additional equipment (changeover switch, timer, and additional contactors), making it relatively more complex and expensive.

6. Switching Transients:

   • DOL Starter: Results in a sudden and high inrush current, which may cause voltage dips in the power supply.
   • Star-Delta Starter: Smooths out the starting current transition by initially using the star connection, reducing the impact on the power supply.

In summary, DOL starters are simpler and cost-effective for smaller motors, while Star-Delta starters are more suitable for larger motors where reducing the starting current is important to avoid power supply issues.

The choice between them depends on the motor size, application requirements, and the electrical infrastructure in place.

The choice between a Direct-On-Line (DOL) starter and a Star-Delta starter depends on various factors, including the size of the motor, application requirements, power system capacity, and the impact of the starting current on the electrical system. Here are some guidelines on when to use DOL and Star-Delta starters:

Use a DOL Starter When:

1. Motor Size: DOL starters are suitable for small to medium-sized motors where the high inrush current is acceptable, and the power supply can handle the sudden starting current without significant voltage drops.

2. Simple Applications: DOL starters are straightforward and cost-effective, making them suitable for applications where the starting characteristics of the motor do not require additional control or where the starting current does not cause issues in the power distribution system.

3. Budget Constraints: If cost is a significant consideration, DOL starters are generally less expensive than more sophisticated starting methods.

4. Power System Capacity: In situations where the power supply has sufficient capacity to handle the high inrush current without causing voltage fluctuations or disturbances.

Use a Star-Delta Starter When:

1. Large Motors: Star-delta starters are commonly used for larger three-phase induction motors, where the starting current is substantial, and reducing it is necessary to avoid power supply issues.

2. Limited Power System Capacity: In cases where the power supply has limited capacity and the high inrush current of a DOL starter could lead to voltage dips or other power quality issues.

3. Smooth Starting Transition is Needed: Applications where a smoother starting transition is required to reduce mechanical stress on the motor and connected equipment.

4. Reduced Mechanical Stress: In situations where minimizing mechanical stress during motor startup is crucial for the longevity of the motor and the driven load.

5. Voltage Drop Concerns: When voltage drops in the electrical distribution system during motor starting needs to be minimized to ensure stable power quality for other connected equipment.

6. Energy Efficiency: In applications where the reduced starting current of a star-delta starter contributes to improved energy efficiency during motor startup.

It’s important to note that modern motor control systems may also use electronic soft starters or variable frequency drives (VFDs) as alternatives to achieve controlled motor starting with even more flexibility and energy efficiency.

The choice between DOL and star-delta starters should be based on a careful assessment of the specific requirements and constraints of the motor and the overall electrical system.